ADR-0057: Autonomous Provider Capability Negotiation & Protocol Handshake v0.3.6

Context & Problem Statement

In heterogeneous multi-provider agent swarms, client agents request domain capabilities (e.g. ast.parse, embedding.dense, eval.matrix) with differing semantic version constraints and feature flags. Without a standardized, bidirectional capability negotiation protocol, version mismatches result in silent runtime deserialization errors, unexpected schema failures, and dropped task executions.

Existing provider discovery scans static manifests on disk, but lacks real-time handshake negotiation, feature flag intersection, and fallback version negotiation.

Proposed Architecture

The Autonomous Provider Capability Negotiation & Protocol Handshake subsystem introduces a structured negotiation engine:

  1. Client Negotiation Request (NegotiationRequest): - Declares required and optional capability sets. - Specifies semver constraint ranges (e.g. >= 1.2.0, < 2.0.0). - Includes client protocol version and supported compression/encoding schemes.

  2. Handshake Negotiation Engine (HandshakeEngine): - Matches requested capabilities against candidate provider manifests. - Evaluates semver compatibility and selects the optimal compatible provider. - Generates a cryptographically signed NegotiationReceipt containing negotiated protocol parameters.

  3. Graceful Fallback & Feature Downgrade: - When preferred capabilities are unavailable, negotiates acceptable fallback tiers. - Rejects unresolvable capability sets with ErrIncompatibleCapabilities.

Verification & Compliance

  • Static Floor Invariant: Enforces schema validation across negotiation requests, capability constraints, and handshake receipts.
  • Operational Dynamic Proof: Validates live bidirectional handshake negotiation, semver resolution, and receipt generation.
  • Negative Adversarial Boundary: Rejects incompatible versions, unfulfillable capability sets, and empty requests.
  • Hygiene & Concurrency: Zero naked goroutines; strict thread safety.